This data dashboard features responses from a quantitative survey of MSMEs. Each survey was administered to a senior manager from an MSME, covering MSME characteristics, current ESG-related policies and standards, ESG-related practices, perceptions of barriers and facilitators, as well as future plans, through a 30-45 minute online/telephone/in-person engagement.
This was supplemented by qualitative, participatory sessions with MSME senior managers and sector-level community representatives to review preliminary survey findings and explore in depth MSME experiences and stakeholder perspectives.
Surveys and roundtables in each country were designed with a common protocol but adapted and conducted with the support of local partners.
In overall and country-level reporting, sectors within each country were directly sampled or reweighted proportionally based on local partner estimates of the country’s sectoral composition. For regional and sector-specific reporting, countries were weighted in equal proportion to ensure that the findings are not skewed by large economies. Total sample sizes are reported for each analysis. Where questions were relevant only to specific subgroups (e.g., MSMEs that had implemented ESG practices), the reported sample size corresponds to the sample size of that subgroup.
| Micro Enterprise | Small Enterprise | Medium Enterprise | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Indonesia | Capital of less than or equal to IDR 1 billion OR annual sales less than or equal to IDR 2 billion | Capital of less than or equal to IDR 5 billion OR annual sales less than or equal to IDR 15 billion | Capital of less than or equal to IDR 10 billion OR annual sales less than or equal to IDR 50 billion |
| Malaysia | Sales turnover of less than RM 300,000 OR less than 5 employees | Manufacturing: Sales turnover of less than RM 15 million OR less than 75 employees
Services: Sales turnover of less than RM 3 million OR less than 30 employees |
Manufacturing: Sales turnover of less than or equal to RM 50 million OR less than or equal to 200 employees
Services: Sales turnover of less than or equal to RM 20 million OR less than or equal to 75 employees |
| Singapore | Operating revenue not exceeding SGD 1 million | Operating revenue not exceeding SGD 10 million | Operating revenue not exceeding SGD 100 million OR no more than 200 employees |
| Micro Enterprise | Small Enterprise | Medium Enterprise | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Revenue | Agriculture, forestry, and fishing industry and construction: Less than or equal to VND 3 billion
Trade and Services: Less than or equal to VND 10 billion |
Agriculture, forestry, and fishing industry and construction: Less than or equal to VND 50 billion
Trade and Services: Less than or equal to VND 100 billion |
Agriculture, forestry, and fishing industry and construction: Less than or equal to VND 200 billion
Trade and Services: Less than or equal to VND 300 billion |
| Total Capital | Less than or equal to VND 3 billion | Manufacturing: Less than or equal to VND 20 billion
Services: Less than or equal to VND 50 billion |
Less than or equal to VND 100 billion |
| Employees with SI Registration | No more than 10 | Agriculture, forestry, and fishing industry and construction: No more than 100 employees
Trade and Services: No more than 50 employees |
Agriculture, forestry, and fishing industry and construction: No more than 200 employees
Trade and Services: No more than 100 employees |
| Inclusion |
|
|---|---|
| Exclusion |
|
| Exception |
|
| Survey | Roundtable | |
|---|---|---|
| Indonesia (ID) | Face-to-face recruitment across 24 provinces with a high concentration of MSMEs, supported by online and telephone surveys for remote regions | Five roundtable discussions conducted in person across five cities (Bali, Jakarta, Medan, Semarang, and Surabaya), each with 7-9 participants |
| Malaysia (MY) | Online and telephone surveys, supplemented with in-person interviews at relevant trade fairs and events | A total of 13 discussions conducted online, with each session focused on a specific sector represented by a maximum of two participants |
| Singapore (SG) | Online survey of Blackbox Research’s established panel of businesses | One roundtable discussion conducted in person with nine participants in Singapore |
| Vietnam (VN) | Mix of online, in-person, and telephone surveys in rural and urban areas, recruiting participants through business associations, national databases, and referral networks | Three roundtable discussions conducted in person in Ho Chi Minh City, each with six participants |
Key Findings for the